Manchester United has long been one of the most celebrated clubs in English football, with a rich history of triumphs in both domestic and international competitions. Whether you’re a devoted Red Devils fan or a neutral observer, the performance of the players is always under close scrutiny, especially as the team navigates through each season.
In this article, we’ll take a look at the latest Manchester United player ratings for the 2023/2024 season, offering insights into individual performances, key matchups, and player contributions that have defined the Red Devils’ journey this season.
Key Factors Affecting Player Ratings
Before diving into individual ratings, it’s important to understand the factors that influence how players are evaluated. In football, player ratings are typically based on several key performance indicators (KPIs), such as:
Goals and Assists: The most obvious indicators of a player’s contribution to a match.
Defensive Contributions: For defenders and defensive midfielders, this includes tackles, interceptions, and aerial duels won.
Passing and Playmaking: Accurate passing, key passes, and link-up play are essential for midfielders and attacking players.
Work Rate and Intensity: Players who press high, recover the ball, and track back to defend often earn praise.
Positioning and Decision Making: Especially for goalkeepers and defenders, reading the game and making the right choices are critical.
Consistency: A player’s overall form across multiple matches is also a significant factor in their ratings.
With this in mind, let’s break down the latest Manchester United player ratings as of October 2024.
Onana (Goalkeeper) – Rating: 7/10
Since his arrival from Inter Milan in the summer of 2023, Andre Onana has faced the tough task of replacing club legend David de Gea. The Cameroonian goalkeeper has shown promise, with his distribution skills and ability to play out from the back being standout features of his game.
In the 2023/2024 season, Onana has delivered solid performances in goal, making crucial saves when called upon. However, some of his performances have been criticized for occasional lapses in concentration and a lack of decisiveness on crosses. Despite these, Onana’s shot-stopping ability remains strong, and he has helped Manchester United secure important clean sheets in matches against tough opposition.
Strengths:
Excellent with the ball at his feet.
Reliable shot-stopper, especially in 1v1 situations.
Weaknesses:
Sometimes shaky on crosses and aerial duels.
Needs to improve communication with defenders.
Aaron Wan-Bissaka (Right-back) – Rating: 6.5/10
Aaron Wan-Bissaka has often divided opinion since his move from Crystal Palace, but in the 2023/2024 season, he has proven his worth in the defensive department. Known for his one-on-one defensive skills and exceptional tackling, Wan-Bissaka has been reliable in restricting opposition wingers.
However, his attacking contributions remain limited. While he has worked on improving his crossing and link-up play, his lack of creativity going forward is still a concern for Manchester United as they look to break down organized defences. His solid performances in big matches have kept him in the starting lineup, but there’s still room for growth.
Strengths:
Excellent tackler and defensive positioning.
Great at blocking crosses and denying wingers.
Weaknesses:
Limited attacking output, especially in the final third.
Needs to improve his crossing and passing under pressure.
Raphaël Varane (Centre-back) – Rating: 7.5/10
Raphaël Varane continues to be one of Manchester United’s most consistent performers at the back. The Frenchman’s ability to read the game and intercept passes is invaluable, and he remains one of the top centre-backs in the Premier League when fully fit.
His partnership with Lisandro Martínez has been solid, although injuries have occasionally disrupted their chemistry. In recent matches, Varane has demonstrated his leadership qualities, organizing the defense and using his experience to shut down dangerous attacks. His form in October 2024 has been particularly solid, and he has proven himself as one of United’s most important defenders.
Strengths:
Superb positioning and reading of the game.
Calm under pressure with excellent aerial ability.
Weaknesses:
Can be prone to injury issues, which affects consistency.
Sometimes caught out against quicker forwards.
Lisandro Martínez (Centre-back) – Rating: 7/10
Lisandro Martínez, known for his aggression and never-say-die attitude, has become a fan favorite at Old Trafford. His physicality and leadership are key attributes in United’s defense, and his partnership with Varane has brought stability to the backline.
However, Martínez has faced some criticism for being caught out in high-pressure situations, especially against fast, powerful strikers. His ability on the ball, though, remains impressive as he often acts as the playmaker from the back, distributing passes with precision and composure. Despite some minor mistakes, his overall impact in defense is undeniable.
Strengths:
Excellent work rate and aggression in duels.
Strong passer from the back and comfortable with the ball at his feet.
Weaknesses:
Prone to occasional lapses in concentration.
Can be exposed against powerful, pacey forwards.
Tyrell Malacia (Left-back) – Rating: 6.5/10
Tyrell Malacia has been a solid addition to the Manchester United defense since his arrival from Feyenoord in 2022. His energy and pace have allowed him to contribute both defensively and in attack. While his defensive positioning is generally sound, his attacking output remains inconsistent.
Malacia has had a relatively quiet season in 2024, with his performances varying in terms of intensity and impact. He remains a dependable option at left-back, but Luke Shaw’s injury concerns have provided Malacia with more game time to prove his worth. If Malacia can develop his offensive game, he’ll become a more well-rounded player.
Strengths:
Great pace and stamina.
Strong tackler and defender in one-on-one situations.
Weaknesses:
Lacks consistency in final third deliveries.
Needs to develop better positional awareness.
Casemiro (Defensive Midfielder) – Rating: 8/10
Casemiro is, without a doubt, one of the best defensive midfielders in the world. Since joining Manchester United from Real Madrid, he has become the cornerstone of the Red Devils’ midfield. His ability to break up opposition attacks, win duels, and distribute the ball has been crucial to the team’s success.
In the 2023/2024 season, Casemiro’s form has been largely impressive, although some of his performances have shown a slight decline in mobility due to his age. Nevertheless, his leadership and experience in high-pressure games make him indispensable to Erik ten Hag’s setup.
Strengths:
Elite tackler and intercepts passes with ease.
Strong leader and organizer in midfield.
Weaknesses:
Can struggle with mobility against high-pressing sides.
Occasionally receives yellow cards for rash tackles.
Bruno Fernandes (Attacking Midfielder) – Rating: 8.5/10
As Manchester United’s captain, Bruno Fernandes has been a key figure in the team’s creative play. Known for his exceptional vision, passing range, and ability to create scoring opportunities, Fernandes has been one of the standout players in the 2023/2024 season.
While his form has been patchy at times, Fernandes continues to contribute with goals and assists, playing a key role in orchestrating Manchester United’s attacking movements. His leadership on the pitch and his ability to provide key passes make him an irreplaceable asset to the team.
Strengths:
Brilliant playmaker with excellent passing range.
A natural leader who elevates the team’s performance.
Weaknesses:
Occasionally inconsistent with decision-making.
Tends to go missing in some high-pressure games.
FAQs
What Are Player Ratings?
Player ratings are a numerical or qualitative way to assess an individual player’s performance in a match. These ratings typically range from 1 to 10, with 10 being a perfect performance and 1 being extremely poor. These ratings are based on several factors, including goals scored, assists, defensive contributions, overall influence on the game, and consistency.
For Manchester United, these ratings are often based on their domestic matches in the Premier League, as well as performances in UEFA Champions League and domestic cup competitions.
What Are the Latest Manchester United Player Ratings for the 2023/2024 Season?
As of October 2024, here are some of the standout ratings for key players:
Bruno Fernandes (Midfielder): 8/10 – Consistently brilliant in creating chances, key passes, and leadership on the field.
Casemiro (Defensive Midfielder): 8/10 – Reliable defensively, breaks up opposition attacks, and provides balance in midfield.
Marcus Rashford (Winger): 7/10 – Though a constant threat with his pace and dribbling, his inconsistency in finishing has been a slight concern.
Rasmus Højlund (Striker): 7/10 – A promising start to his United career, but still adapting to the Premier League.
Raphaël Varane (Centre-back): 7.5/10 – Strong in defense, particularly in aerial duels, though his fitness has been tested at times.
While some players, like Fernandes and Casemiro, have been consistent, others, like Rashford and Højlund, have shown flashes of brilliance but need to improve their consistency to achieve higher ratings.
Who Has the Highest Rating for Manchester United in 2023/2024?
As of the latest updates, Bruno Fernandes is widely regarded as having the highest player ratings. His ability to dictate play, create chances, and score goals has made him a central figure for United. His leadership as the captain has been evident, and he continues to be the team’s creative heartbeat. He has maintained a rating of 8/10 in many games due to his consistent contribution in attack and midfield.
How Are Manchester United Player Ratings Determined?
Player ratings are determined through a combination of factors, including:
Goals and Assists: Players who score or assist goals naturally tend to receive higher ratings.
Defensive Contribution: Defenders and defensive midfielders are rated on tackles, interceptions, clearances, and blocks.
Passing and Playmaking: The ability to create chances and maintain possession is critical, particularly for midfielders and forwards.
Work Rate: Players who press high, recover possession, and show tactical discipline are often given better ratings.
Consistency: A player’s level of performance across multiple games affects their overall rating.
These ratings are typically compiled by football analysts, sports journalists, and fan polls, with individual fan websites or platforms like WhoScored, SofaScore, and BBC Sport offering their own assessments.
What Are the Common Ratings for Manchester United’s Defenders?
Defenders typically receive ratings based on their ability to stop attacks, maintain clean sheets, and contribute to the team’s overall defensive organization.
Raphaël Varane (7.5/10): His leadership and defensive contributions have made him a reliable figure at the back, particularly in key aerial duels.
Lisandro Martínez (7/10): A strong presence with his aggressive style of play, although his height is occasionally a disadvantage against more physical attackers.
Aaron Wan-Bissaka (6.5/10): Known for his defensive solidity, Wan-Bissaka has struggled in the attacking third, with his offensive output often falling short.
Conclusion
Manchester United player ratings are more than just numbers—they reflect the expectations and emotions of a global fanbase. For supporters, these ratings provide a tangible way to assess how their favorite players are performing throughout the season. The fluctuating ratings highlight the highs and lows of each match and often reflect the broader narrative of the season.
Player ratings help fans analyze strengths and weaknesses, while offering valuable insights into how individual players are contributing to the team’s success. Whether it’s Bruno Fernandes pulling the strings in midfield, Casemiro breaking up opposition attacks, or Marcus Rashford’s streaky form in front of goal, these ratings offer a snapshot of Manchester United’s ongoing journey in the Premier League and beyond.
To read more, Click here.
